Ultimate Guide To Once Upon a Broken Heart series by Stephanie Garber

The Once Upon a Broken Heart series by Stephanie Garber is a captivating fantasy romance that blends magic, mystery, and the enchantment of fairy tales. Set In the same world as Garber’s Caraval series, this new adventure introduces readers to new characters and weaves a spellbinding tale filled with twists, intrigue, and romance.

Once Upon a Broken Heart series by Stephanie Garber

Is it necessary to read the Carval series by Stephanie Graber before starting the Once Upon a Broken Heart series?

No. However, reading Caraval first is highly recommended for a richer understanding of the world-building and characters.

Here’s why:

  • Shared Universe and Characters: The Once Upon a Broken Heart series is set in the same magical universe as the Caraval series and includes some overlapping characters, particularly Jacks, the Prince of Hearts, who plays a significant role in both series. Reading Caraval first will give you more background on Jacks and his motivations.
  • Easter Eggs and Deeper Context: If you’re familiar with the Caraval world, you’ll pick up on hidden Easter eggs and understand the plot elements and character dynamics in Once Upon a Broken Heart.
  • Independent Storyline: Even though Once Upon a Broken Heart is set in the same universe as Caraval, it reads as a standalone story. It introduces new protagonists, magical adventures, and a different plot arc.

So, while you can dive right into Once Upon a Broken Heart without reading Caraval, you might enjoy it even more with the context that the Caraval series provides!

Overview of the Series

The Once Upon a Broken Heart series centers around Evangeline Fox, a young woman whose life turns upside down when she makes a desperate bargain with the manipulative yet alluring Prince of Hearts, Jacks.

Evangeline’s story is one of love, betrayal, and the dangerous consequences of striking deals with those who wield powerful magic.

Book 1: Once Upon a Broken Heart

Book 1: Once Upon a Broken Heart

TAGS: Enemies to Lovers, Deal with the Devil, Fated Lovers, Love Triangle, Forbidden Love, Mysterious Loner with a Dark Past, Hidden Agendas and Secrets, The Chosen One, Fairy Tale Elements, Unexpected Alliances

CONTENT WARNINGS: Blood and Injury, Death and Grief, Manipulation and Betrayal, Violence, Magical Coercion, Toxic Relationships, Mind Games and Psychological Manipulation, Unreliable Narrators and Ambiguous Morality

Rating: ★★★


Once Upon a Broken Heart by Stephanie Garber is the first installment in a captivating fantasy romance series that delves into a world of magic, mystery, and romance.

The story centers on Evangeline Fox, a young woman whose life is upended when she experiences a profound betrayal. Heartbroken and desperate, Evangeline makes a treacherous deal with the Prince of Hearts, a powerful and enigmatic figure known for his cunning and charm. This bargain leads her into a whirlwind of magical intrigue and danger as she navigates a world where nothing is as it seems and every choice has significant consequences.

As Evangeline’s journey unfolds, she encounters fascinating characters and becomes entangled in a complex web of magic and deception. The narrative weaves themes of love, betrayal, and the high cost of bargains with those who wield immense power.

Garber’s storytelling is rich and immersive, with a vibrant setting and a plot full of unexpected twists. The novel combines elements of fairy tale enchantment with a fresh and engaging narrative, making it a compelling read for fans of magical romance and fantasy adventures.

Once Upon a Broken Heart sets the stage for a thrilling series, blending emotional depth with a spellbinding plot.

Key Themes and Elements:

  • Magic and Mysticism: richly imagined world where magic is a tangible and influential force.
  • Romantic Entanglements: intense romantic and emotional conflicts.
  • Bargains and Consequences: The central theme revolves around the high stakes of magical bargains and their repercussions.

Book 2: The Ballad of Never After

TAGS: Star-Crossed Lovers, The Reluctant Heroine, Unreliable Allies, Forbidden Magic and Dangerous Deals, Court Intrigue and Betrayal, Morally Gray Characters, Cursed Objects and Places, Fated Prophecies and Curses

CONTENT WARNINGS: Blood, Injury, and Violence, Manipulation and Betrayal, Psychological and Emotional Abuse, Toxic Relationships, Mentions of Poisoning and Drugging

Rating: ★★★★★


The Ballad of Never After continues the enthralling story from Stephanie Garber’s Once Upon a Broken Heart series, diving deeper into a world where magic and mystery intertwine with romance.

In this sequel, Evangeline Fox’s journey takes on new dimensions as she grapples with the consequences of her previous choices and the repercussions of the bargain she struck with the Prince of Hearts. As she navigates a world filled with magical intrigue, betrayal, and romance, Evangeline must confront the shadows of her past and the complexities of her current situation.

The story picks up with Evangeline facing the fallout of her actions and dealing with new challenges that test her resolve and loyalty. She encounters allies and adversaries in her quest for resolution and redemption, all while the stakes continue to rise.

The novel delves deeper into the lore and magic of the series’ universe, offering readers a richer understanding of the characters and their motivations.

Garber’s signature blend of lush, evocative world-building and compelling character development continues to shine in this installment. The plot is filled with unexpected twists and turns, keeping readers engaged and eager to see how Evangeline’s story will unfold.

The Ballad of Never After preserves the captivating charm and enchanting drama that made its predecessor irresistible. It sets the stage for further adventures and developments in the series, ensuring that fans will be eagerly anticipating the next chapter in Evangeline’s magical journey. In my opinion, this is the best book in the series.

Key Themes and Elements:

Emotional Depth: The book explores deeper emotional and relational complexities

Growth and Redemption: Evangeline’s personal development and quest for redemption are central to the story.

Expanding the Magical World: The sequel delves further into the lore and magical elements introduced in the first book.


Book 3: A Curse for True Love

TAGS: Redemption Arc, Dark Fairy Tale Elements, Sacrifice for Love, Moral Ambiguity and Complex Characters, Betrayal and Trust Issues, The Price of Magic, Fated Prophecies and Destiny, Memory Loss, Star-Crossed Lovers

CONTENT WARNINGS: Toxic Relationships and Power Imbalances, Mind Games and Gaslighting, Memory Loss and Identity Crisis, Dark Magic and Curses

Rating: ★★★★


A Curse for True Love concludes Stephanie Garber’s Once Upon a Broken Heart series with a finale brimming with magic, romance, and resolution.

Following the twists and turns of the previous installments, this book brings Evangeline Fox’s journey to a thrilling and emotional climax.

As the story unfolds, Evangeline faces the ultimate test of her strength and resolve. The stakes are higher than ever as she contends with the powerful forces and dark curses that have shaped her journey.

The consequences of her past decisions and bargains come to a head, unveiling the cost of love and sacrifice.

In this final chapter, Garber deepens the intricate world-building and character development that have defined the series. Evangeline’s quest for true love and redemption leads her through a landscape of familiar and new magical realms.

She confronts the shadows of her past while navigating treacherous alliances and uncovering long-hidden truths.

The Ballad of Never After concludes with a blend of enchantment, suspense, and heartfelt moments. Garber’s storytelling shines as she ties together the various threads of the series, delivering a satisfying and poignant resolution to Evangeline’s story.

A Curse for True Love is a fitting conclusion to a tale of love, betrayal, and the transformative power of magic, culminating in a satisfying fairytale ending.

Key Themes and Elements:

  • Resolution and Closure: The book aims to provide closure to the overarching narrative and character arcs.
  • Thematic Consistency: It continues to explore themes of love, sacrifice, and the consequences of magical bargains.
  • Emotional and Dramatic Finale: The series concludes with a blend of emotional resolution and dramatic events.

Final Thoughts

As we look back on the conclusion of the Once Upon a Broken Heart series, we immerse ourselves in a journey filled with enchantment, intrigue, and emotional depth.

Stephanie Garber’s masterful storytelling has taken us through a world where love, betrayal, and the magic of choices intertwine to create an undeniably memorable saga.

Throughout this series, we’ve been captivated by the rich settings, intricate plot twists, and the personal growth of our beloved characters. Each installment drew us deeper into a universe where every decision and bargain has far-reaching consequences, highlighting the delicate balance between desire and sacrifice.

With A Curse for True Love providing a poignant and satisfying conclusion, we witness the culmination of themes that have resonated throughout the series—love’s enduring power, the cost of sacrifice, and the quest for resolution.


Once Upon a Broken Heart series by Stephanie Garber

Why You’ll Love The Series:

  1. Enchanting World-Building: Dive into a richly imagined world where magic, mystery, and intrigue blend seamlessly. Stephanie Garber creates an immersive universe that will captivate your imagination.
  2. Complex Characters: The series features well-developed characters with intricate backstories and evolving arcs. You’ll find yourself deeply invested in their journeys, relationships, and personal growth.
  3. Romantic Twists: Experience a captivating romance that intertwines with the central plot, offering heartwarming and heart-wrenching moments. The series explores themes of love, betrayal, and second chances in a way that resonates deeply.
  4. Intricate Plot: The series maintains the reader’s interest with its engaging plot twists, vivid world-building, and complex characters. Each book builds suspense and delivers satisfying resolutions, making it a gripping read from start to finish.
  5. Emotional Depth: The series delves into profound themes such as sacrifice, identity, and the consequences of choices. It challenges readers to reflect on their own experiences and emotions.
  6. Stunning Prose: Garber’s lyrical and evocative writing style enhances the storytelling, adding layers of beauty and depth to the narrative.

Why it might not be the right choice for some readers:

Romantic Themes: If you’re not a fan of romance or find it distracting in your reading, the central focus on love, relationships, and romantic entanglements might not appeal to you.

Fantasy Tropes: If you’re not fond of fantasy tropes like magical bargains, enchanted worlds, or mythical creatures, the series might feel too familiar or predictable.

Pacing: The pacing can vary, with some readers finding certain parts slower or more detailed than they prefer. If you’re looking for fast-paced action throughout, this series might not meet those expectations.

Similar Posts

One Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *